There was snow on the ground, I’m sure about that, for now still a safe enough bet for Northwestern Wisconsin in winter. Maybe it was snowing. If I noticed the weather, I didn’t think to write it down, and now the fact escapes me.
Dad was dead, no changing the facts, and death didn’t seem reason enough to call a stranger out of bed over the Christmas holiday. Dad was dead, but this had been going on for a while. Like the old tale of the boiling frog, who doesn’t leap from a pot of tepid water being heated and so is gradually cooked, we had gotten kind of used to it.
+
Remembering is difficult. I gloss over how it was. How Dad didn’t realize he was sick, how the limits of his comprehension slowly vanished inward, backward, and went on narrowing. How tiring it was to pretend for him, to repeat and to be repeated to, endlessly circling the truth. How tired and fearful I felt. How impossibly strong his hands remained, gripping and wringing my wrists and fingers, how it seemed he might break them when he clung. How young for the disease, and how I thought he could live for years and decades, live and live and live. How relieved I was, how heartsick, how selfish, how tired.
How I love the smells of engine grease and cut grass, late summer tomato leaves, hot steam wafting from ironed cotton, damp snow on a coat collar. How I always notice the price of bananas.
Later, I realized I should have been writing it down.
+
We were outsiders. When I was born, my parents moved to a small town where everyone knew everyone, and most people were related in one way or another. We, my parents and my brother and I, weren’t related to anyone, and my dad’s thoughts about independence and nepotism, sometimes shared at town meetings, didn’t win him any popularity contests. My entire life until I left for college was in this town, and I never felt like I fit there. I felt too seen and also too invisible. Maybe I would be a writer and go to a city and disappear and be famous. Maybe I would never look back.
I believe my dad would have recognized those feelings, the longing to escape, and some of his biography bears out this belief. But he didn’t talk about it much, and he didn’t write it down.
+
My parents, like lots of couples who married young (she was twenty-two, he was twenty-five) had their share of ups and downs, though they stayed married until my dad’s death, forty-some years in all. For all the years I can remember, something was going on with Dad, something unnamed that caused him sometimes to emanate a cold, pressured silence, a silence that might simply dissipate or else be broken by shouting or, I figured out, a well-timed joke. When he was happy, everyone was happy, or so it seemed to me, but happiness was not a steady state.
Something was going on with Dad. He worked a lot, his back hurt, he wanted everything for us. He was stressed, depressed, deprived of sleep. He cut out meat, lost twenty pounds. He bought capsules and supplements and a water distillation unit. His colonoscopy, he was proud to say, showed the colon of a person half his age. He was strong as the proverbial ox.
Later, I realized he must have been afraid.
+
In most of the memories I have of my dad, he is working.
For the work he did outside of his job—gardening, canning, preparing our meals—there were plaid button downs and two or three sets of bib overalls in various stages of decay. In the small-engine repair shop he ran out of our garage, he wore navy blue work pants and matching shirts, carefully ironed by my mom, with his name embroidered on a patch over the breast pocket. The shop smelled of grease and engine oil and gasoline and dust, though it wasn’t an especially dusty place considering that my brother and I were regularly tasked with keeping the floors swept and the shelves, the counter, and the sale display of new lawn mower engines wiped clean with squares of our old clothes cut into rags.
The shop was a just-so kind of place, with boxes of machine parts classified according to a numeric system that matched those listed in a set of large three-ring binders, with tool cabinets so organized that Dad could reach for and locate a specific wrench without taking his eyes from the repair. Dad believed that a tidy shop showed customers the care they could expect from his repair work.
Later, I wondered whether this carefully controlled environment had helped him compensate when he could tell that something wasn’t right.
+
On a typical day, Dad would be up early, measuring grounds into the 12-cup countertop drip unit so he and Mom could enjoy a coffee and some quiet minutes together. Dad took his with two spoons of sugar and a splash of half-and-half, and I learned to like coffee by stealing sips from his mug.
Then he’d be fixing breakfast, scrambled eggs with sausage or biscuits and gravy, and even on the coldest winter days, taking Mom’s car for a spin to gas it up and get the heater going for her. Once she waited and waited for him to return with her car, growing increasingly pissed as the start of her workday grew closer. When he finally returned, he didn’t grasp her irritation. He’d stopped for milk, picked up the mail, was it some kind of big deal? It wasn’t really like him to lose track, but with a household to juggle and a small business to run, things were bound to get mixed up.
He’d always been a little scatterbrained, forgetting to drop my brother off at kindergarten, leaving his wallet in various hiding spots around the house, or squirreling cash in a coat pocket and then forgetting where it was: my mom tells a story of my Sunday School teacher letting her know how the class had prayed for my dad at my request, related to “a lot of money that he lost.” The teacher was polite but clearly horrified, probably assuming he had gambled it away.
My dad never gambled, said he worked too hard to hand it off that easily. But once, when my grandma to visit, we stopped at a casino. Did my brother and I stay in the lobby or in the car? Were we allowed to wait in the restaurant sipping Cokes? In any case, my mom and grandma played five or ten bucks at the nickel slots, and Dad walked out with a few coins he’d found scattered on the floor, pleased to be the only one to come out ahead.
+
Dad prided himself on frugality and never spoke of generosity. But every summer, when I was seven and eight and nine and ten, he sent me to the elderly apartments across the street, where I had to pull our red wagon full of garden produce from door to door, giving away cucumbers and rhubarb and tomatoes to very many very old-seeming ladies, only a few old men, and have my braids tugged and be called pretty and plied with Country Time lemonade and frosted cookies from a plastic clamshell.
He made weekly batches of homemade soup for a terminally ill friend who couldn’t eat much else.
He would plow the sidewalk for the entire block.
He always went to the funeral.
+
Dad loved wacky, sometimes elaborate jokes, often performed early in the morning before any witnesses were stirring.
He set up a campsite in the neighbors’ yard, waking them at sunrise to the clatter of their breakfast being cooked over a fire.
Another neighbor was meticulous about his lawn in a mostly friendly competition with my dad, who mowed ours all the time to test repairs. In the dead of winter, my dad built a six-foot snowman in the yard next door, gloved stick arms pushing a Lawn Boy, pencil dangling like a Marlboro where a snowman’s mouth would be, in clear resemblance of his rival.
+
When we got a new stereo, he tested the speakers one dawn by playing at full volume a compact disc of freight train sounds next to my visiting grandma, asleep and unsuspecting on the hide-a-bed. She was terrified and then furious, but he laughed like a gleeful teenager until she could see the joke and laughed with him.
Around the time I started middle school, he created arrangements of more than sixty plastic flamingos, a flock which appeared to migrate each morning on their own around the yard of our Main Street house, sometimes wearing costumes: American flags and paper hats on the 4th of July, backpacks on the first day of school. Once, a long row of flamingos peered over the lattice rails of our broad front porch, a single bird lying on the lawn among the shredded remains of a pink feather duster beside a seven-foot inflatable alligator. They were on clearance, my dad shrugged, and when in their natural habitat does one see only one or two flamingos?
+
When I was thirteen, my mom earned her master’s degree and got a better-paying job, and this must have allowed my dad some personal permission to occasionally relax. In those years, he took meandering country drives, sometimes met a friend for coffee, and perfected his banana bread recipe. At some point, he taught himself to tie fishing flies. Tying flies was fussy, delicate work performed through the lens of a lighted magnifying glass. Maybe he used the flies to fish, but mostly I remember the glint of the barbed hooks, the contrasting softness of feathers and fur, the slight movements of his strong hands winding a nearly invisible thread. I suppose the point is that he was enterprising, industrious, could study and observe and figure things out.
+
We generally got along, Dad and I, particularly if there wasn’t too much talk involved. With his friends and customers, or with servers or salespeople, he could be charismatic and hilariously quick-witted, and babies were drawn to his solemn winks. But he tended to quiet contemplation when he was tired, or stern monologues if he perceived my behavior or attitude merited correction, or simmering silent rages for entirely unpredictable reasons. I don’t think he was always this way, but this is the way I knew him.
Sometimes as a teen, I would accompany him on quiet evening outings. In the spring, we would crawl along the country lanes in his station wagon, “bunny hunting,” he called it, watching for the frolics of tiny fawn-colored baby rabbits, stopping the car when we spotted them and sharing a laugh over their adorable antics, their absolute tininess. In the summer, I lounged across the station wagon’s bench seat reading my paperback copy of Ovid’s Metamorphoses while he cast a dozen times into a trout stream. In the winter, we took turns breaking trail on our snowshoes along the fence line of a tree farm. On cold days, we saw our breath. We saw deer and hawks, broken furniture and abandoned television sets. I don’t remember whether he caught fish. I don’t remember what we talked about, if we talked at all.
+
After I was off to college, my brother told me later, Dad came back from the funeral of an elderly friend who, toward the end of his life, forgot his work, his friends, his children, his wife. “Take the shotgun,” Dad wanted him to promise, “and shoot me if I ever get like that.”
+
The summer of 2001 was officially the future, and I had recently graduated with a BA in English Literature, so I was back at home, living in my childhood bedroom and reading poetry books from the library, applying for MFA programs, waiting tables to save up money either on the chance I’d go to grad school or the chance I wouldn’t. In the meantime, my dad and I decided to take a class together at the community center: lacing snowshoes.
We sat beside each other in the circle of students, and the instructor first demonstrated, then buzzed around, answering questions, troubleshooting. I no longer remember the technique, just that we were weaving neoprene strips into pre-built frames. No, I was weaving. The instructor stood for a moment behind my dad, then showed him once more how to twist the strips into a pattern. In this moment, Dad would have cracked a joke balanced with the right amount of self-deprecation, and the instructor would have chuckled and moved along, satisfied.
Except Dad couldn’t figure out what to do. His hands and his brain, so used to solving far more complicated tasks, couldn’t coordinate to weave the pattern. Back and forth, I moved between our frames, tidying his web and then completing mine, smiling too much, keeping up a light chatter between me and my dad in the space where before was our comfortable understanding with silence.
+
I think my brother has it now, the little stepstool that Dad built for us when we were small. Simple but sturdy, it stayed tucked under the bathroom sink long after we didn’t need it to wash our hands and brush our teeth. Before we were born, before work took all his energy, Dad built a lot of things–jewelry boxes, cabinets, all the tables in our house. His own dad died when he was sixteen (steel mill, lung cancer), and though he didn’t talk about it much, it was clear that this trauma put into him a terror of lacking money, food, security. Work feathered the nest, protected us, and he worked for long hours in every season. Even at mealtimes, customers might knock on the door, and Dad would leave his dinner to help offload a busted snowblower from a pickup or swap a toothy skein of freshly sharpened saw chains for a folded square of cash. As I lay drowsy in my bed at night, I could often hear the long screech of the bench grinder, picture the amber sparks spitting from the blade’s edge.
+
The last year my parents lived in my childhood house, I was home with my own kids for a visit. My son was five years old, my dad’s pal, and Papa would help him build his own little stepstool. After an hour, my son wandered away for a snack, to play with trucks, to see what his toddler sister was doing. My dad was frustrated: damn thing wouldn’t come together. He fumbled with the wood, a four-piece puzzle that wouldn’t fit, but by that afternoon, or maybe the next, a little step stool was complete, if just a bit off-kilter. It might be the last thing Dad built on his own, this little stepstool he and my son painted fire-engine red, a project that should have taken maybe thirty minutes to complete.
+
Mom’s work was busy and fulfilling. She excelled at it and earned a new position and sometimes had to travel. My dad managed the house, the meals, the grocery shopping. He reveled in the bargain-hunting element of grocery shopping, and if we spoke on the phone in those days, it was either about my kids or a good price on bananas.
One weekend, Mom went searching for something in the back storage room of the basement and came across rows upon rows of boxed cereals and pastas and a huge assortment of canned goods, several years’ worth of groceries, many items already expired. An enormous, overwhelming, totally bonkers hoard, a sheer amount that made her sob, because making this discovery was the moment when she knew.
+
And so, my mom retired, and my parents moved from the edge of the countryside out to the middle of it, to a ranch house on an idyllic apple orchard where they could see foxes and deer cross the backyard, an Edenic spot where in fact they posed for their holiday card as Adam and Eve, bare skin peeking out from behind carefully arranged apple leaves.
For me, the joke didn’t land, not with my dad both there and gone, both laughing and maybe not always in on it. After they moved to the orchard house, it was like his mind could never be unpacked. The new place had a large garage with a workspace for his shop and that was never unpacked either. Over the years, imperceptibly to the rest of us, his tall red Snap-On cabinets had slowly lost their perfect order, and no one now could set them right. Dad might slide a drawer open but never seemed to know what he was looking for. The sockets weren’t organized by set, the wrenches not ordered by size, and he would be frustrated and angry and close the drawer. Without the familiar surroundings of his shop, the small town, the house he’d lived in nearly 40 years, the muscle memories of his usual places, he became increasingly agitated, increasingly childlike. The first year, they planted a garden, but without Dad’s careful tending, it grew disheveled and weedy, and after that there was no more garden.
Eventually, he could no longer cook or drive or understand money. Spoons vanished regularly from the kitchen drawer, and Mom would find them all around the house: in the desk cubbies, in the basement freezer, tucked inside his folded pairs of clean underwear. He tried to wear two pairs of pants or put socks on his hands instead of gloves. He took a pot of black-eyed peas off the stove and tried to carry them to the garage “for the people who live out there.” Television confused him; he thought the shows were happening in the house with him, and he despised Pat Sajak for giving all that money to other people and never to him.
It was sad, of course, but sometimes it was funny.
+
When she was packing up their house, my mom found a sticky note on the back of the coffee maker, the one they’d had for years, the one he used every morning. In his careful, Catholic-school handwriting, he had listed the steps for brewing coffee.
+
Once, as I was heading to my car at the end of a visit, he handed me his handkerchief, carefully folded into a packet, with two or three wheat pennies and a dime inside, a little something for the kids.
It was funny, of course, but sometimes it was sad.
+
Later, I would wonder if what I had understood to be his personality was some truer self, the one who loved to laugh and read and cook and care for us, already being eroded. I like to think about his younger, carefree self, the one who borrowed his unsuspecting mother’s car to go fishing and ended up instead on an impulsive weeks-long road trip to see the far-off desert and the redwoods and the California coast. Or better, the ten-year-old fishing the dam with his dad, or the toddler he once described in his earliest memory: eating a cookie and being pushed in a stroller along sunny squares of sidewalk by his grandmother.
+
To remember, one must accept the version that really happened, the ways in which life changed us, despite our efforts otherwise.
He intended self-reliance to safeguard him, to protect my brother and me, to break a cycle of family trauma and alcoholism and anyone’s guess about the other things because he never said. He wouldn’t like me telling any of this, but it’s my story too, even if it disappoints the dead. It’s the story I want my kids to know. Writing down these memories is my version of feathering the nest.
+
My dad died from complications due to Alzheimer’s disease on December 26, 2017. It was almost midnight. It was snowing and it was dark. It was dark. I don’t remember if it was snowing. I was in the next room, and my mom came to get me, and we called my brother to come. The house was very quiet, and the world was very quiet, and I don’t remember how I felt. One by one, we sat with him, and I told him things I won’t write down. The sky grew pale and pink, and my mom called the hospice nurse, and someone called the coroner, and the black van came, and the white van came, and then they drove away.
Sara Wainscott is the author of Insecurity System (Persea, 2020), winner of the Lexi Rudtnitsky First Book Prize, and The Star Cabins (Rescue Press, 2026). She is the recipient of a fellowship from the Civitella Ranieri Foundation, a Newcity “Lit 50” honoree for Chicago literary influencers, and the former co-curator of the Wit Rabbit Reading Series. She lives in Chicago.
Photo by: Aditya Vyas on Unsplash
